Local Residents to defend historic role of juries outside Birmingham Crown Court

On Monday 4 December from 8:45am until 10am, a group of Birmingham residents will join hundreds of others around the country in holding signs outside Birmingham Crown Court, as part of the growing public campaign Defend Our Juries. Their signs display the centuries-old principle of ‘jury equity’, i.e. the right of all jurors in British courtrooms to acquit a defendant according to their conscience and irrespective of the directions of the judge. Famously, in 1984, a jury acquitted the civil servant, Clive Ponting, on this principle after he exposed government misinformation to the public and Parliament concerning the ‘Falklands War’

Protesters holding signs outside Birmingham Crown Court

Risk of arrest

By displaying these signs, the group runs the risk of arrest. In September, the Solicitor General announced he would prosecute the 68-year retired social worker, Trudi Warner, for contempt of court, for holding a similar sign outside Inner London Crown Court in March. Then in October, two young women were arrested by the MET police for doing the same thing.

Collective action works

There are strong indications that united, collective action to defend the principle of jury equity is proving effective. Just days after the Solicitor General’s announcement to prosecute Warner, 252 people gathered outside 25 crown courts across England and Wales, holding similar signs in solidarity with Trudi Warner. None were arrested and there has been no indication of a police investigation since then. An investigation into people previously arrested for displaying posters with the same message has now been discontinued.

The Defend our Juries campaign  has gathered powerful support from eminent professors of law, such as Professor Richard Vogler and Professor John Spencer. In the words of Professor Vogler:

“George Orwell noticed the tendency of repressive law to degenerate into farce, when truth becomes a lie and common sense is heresy. This is worth remembering now that the solicitor general, Michael Tomlinson KC, has concluded that it is right to take action against … Trudi Warner, for holding up a sign outside a criminal court, simply proclaiming one of the fundamental principles of the common law: the right of a jury to decide a case according to its conscience.”

Mounting concern over jury trial

The demonstrations come soon after the trial in October at Wolverhampton Crown Court of a protester who was charged with criminal damage of £500k to property belonging to Arconic (which supplied the cladding held responsible for spreading the Grenfell Tower blaze; and also manufactures components for helicopters and jets supplied to Israel).   The jury unanimously found the defendant Not Guilty.

Measures to stop juries reaching not guilty verdicts

Measures being taken by courts in response include defendants being banned from explaining to the jury why they did what they did, even people who have taken peaceful direct action are now being sent to prison for up to 3 years. In some cases, people have been sent to prison just for trying to explain their actions to the jury for saying the words ‘climate change’ and ‘fuel poverty’ in court. Defendants are banned from explaining the principle of ‘jury equity’ to the jury, even though it is a well established principle of law, which is set in marble at the original entrance to the Old Bailey.

Local residents take part 

Explaining why they are prepared to risk arrest for this legal principle local resident, Emma Cooper, aged 32, from Lichfield said:,

“I’m doing this because it’s so important that the legal system does not stop people from telling the whole truth in court, and does not stop jurors from making the decision they think is right when they have all the information. Our society often seems to allow those in power to lie with impunity, but the truth - the whole truth - ought to matter. At times like these, it is more important than ever that rights which have been enshrined in law for hundreds of years are not abandoned.”

Richard Painter, aged 62, from Birmingham, said: 

“Juries are a common sense check on the law. They ensure that judges, law makers and governments cannot abuse their power and use British courtrooms to do their dirty work for them. 

"The right of juries to acquit a defendant according to their conscience has been enshrined in British Law for centuries, and we must protect it. I am here to send a clear message to Judges that the public won’t stand for the important role jurors have being made a mockery of. 

"Let our juries hear the whole truth and let them reach a fair and true verdict without judicial interference!”

Protesters holding signs outside Birmingham Crown Court

About Defend our Juries


Defend our Juries is a new campaign with the following aims:

  1. to bring to public attention the programme to undermine trial by jury in the context of those taking action to expose government dishonesty and corporate greed
  2. to raise awareness of the vital constitutional safeguard that juries can acquit a defendant as a matter of conscience, irrespective of a judge’s direction that there is no available defence (a principle also known as ‘jury equity’ or ‘jury nullification‘)
  3. to ensure that all defendants have the opportunity to explain their actions when their liberty is at stake, including by explaining their motivations and beliefs.

Resources

See Defend Our Juries website: https://defendourjuries.org/

“Defying a judge is not always contempt of court” (The Times, behind a paywall)

“Trudi Warner reveals the dark secret of English courts: juries do have the right to follow their consciences” (The Guardian, 27 September)

“A climate of injustice” (the Ecologist)

“Charge us with contempt too, say 40 people, if climate activist prosecuted” (Guardian, 17 August)

See also the short film, “Right to Acquit”